User centered web design is not a new idea to increase internet sales, but it is proven to work. Seth Godin’s book The Big Red Fez explains how to make any website better and increase traffic and profits. He likes to associate each successful website as a “monkey in a big red fez.” The way to motivate a monkey to do what you want is to use a “banana.” Godin says that “if the banana isn’t easy to see, easy to get and obvious, the monkey is going to lose interest. But if you make it clear to the monkey what’s in it for him, odds are he’ll do what you what.”
This is the same for any internet site. Each page needs a “banana” or clear purpose to help the user know what their next step should be. Therefore, if you want a user to purchase the item you are selling on a page, the “banana” should be the clearly marked purchase button. The user should know right away that this is the next step in purchasing that item.
Godin uses multiple examples of how a poor website can be made better. Here are the examples I feel best support a user centered design and why.
1. The best way to get what you want
This of course is to make the “banana” the obvious choice on the page. I recently found this to be anything but true this last election night. After the polls closed on election night, I, like most people interested in the election, went to the internet to get specific results of individual races. I wanted to get specific numbers for the local congressional races and knew that Fox News and CNN have had great graphics and statistics for each state on their websites. I first started with Fox and to my surprise, I couldn’t find any links on the front page for individual state races. I could find out about the Republicans taking over the House and the fight for the Senate, but I couldn’t find a link for the local Reed-Keller race. I gave up and went to CNN. CNN had the same stories on their front page, but again I couldn’t find individual state races. Unlike what most users would have done, I didn’t give up and started to search the website. I eventually found what I was looking for, but I went through so many pages and links, that I was afraid to close the page in fear that I would never find it again. It should be noted that the information CNN had was wonderful. It gave maps of each state, color coded to show which congressional districts were Democrat and which were Republican. It also gave detailed election results for every Congressional race. The question that I kept asking myself was, if they have this great webpage that must have cost a fortune to develop, why aren’t they showcasing it on their homepage on election night?
2. Don’t make it easy for you, make it easy for me
I hate pull down menus. I mean I really hate them. Especially, pull down menus that involve me having to find the United States in alphabetical order. I mean how many people from Uganda are using the same website I am to the point that they are listed before the good old USA? Why not put the United States, Canada, United Kingdom at the top of the list and then list Andorra through Zimbabwe. Or even better, put the US as default and have all the shoppers from Uganda use the pull down.
I also hate the fact that New York is never on the initial drop down menu and you have to scroll to find it. This adds two more steps in the process for me when I could have just typed the letters NY.
3. You can’t test everything
Nothing is more frustrating then when you’re on a page that times you out or you have to continuously log back in. Although it is not a consumer site, the best example of this frustration is the my.sbu, mybudget page. This St. Bonaventure University internal page allows departments the ability to view their budgets down to specific object codes. However, if you so much as want to view a few different codes in a row, it logs you out because the maximum amount of cookie values has been reached. St. Bonaventure has a good size IT department and spends a lot of money on programs such as mybudget. Why on earth can’t you do all the work you need before it logs you out. I mean is the Taliban making so many transactions by viewing my department’s budget that for security reasons they can’t give me unlimited cookie values?

4. Hi, can I help you
I recently bought a new flat screen television from Radio Shack for a reduced price, because it was the floor model. The problem was it didn’t come with a factory remote. So I needed a replacement remote control for my television. Have you ever tried to purchase one of these? It’s nearly impossible. First I went directly to the Samsung webpage. It sounded like the logical place to go. There must be thousands of people who lose their remotes and need replacement. Well apparently at Samsung, if you lose your remote, you have to purchase a new television, or a LCD projector or a blu-ray player. I typed replacement remote, which I thought would be a common search and this is what I got:

Do you see any remotes on this page? Well scroll down and you won’t see any either. They didn’t even acknowledge that my search turned up nothing. They simple said there were 2,779 results for replacement remotes. If there are any remotes on this site, I’m not going to scroll through hundreds of pages to find it.
5. The web is not a catalog
Since I could not find a replacement remote at Samsung directly, I turned to Google for help. I searched and found the site, replacementremotes.com. Sounds good, right? Well the site sort of looks unprofessional and my original thought was, is this a legit website? Anyway, I persevered and did a search for Samsung and the model number (I can’t remember the actual model number, but I digress). Low and behold, I got nothing. So I entered only Samsung and this is what I got:

This is the bottom of the page and look, first it is listed by model number (why didn’t the search work) and second, there are five pages listed and then a button for the next 20. The next 20 pages! I stopped there defeated and decided to buy a universal remote from Wal-Mart. The good news was, before I did this, Radio Shack called and had found the remote.
6. Let them look all they want
I believe the examples I’m going to give have changed, but a few years ago if you tried to watch a video on a news site like Fox News or a television show on a network site like ABC, you had to log in. This means I had to give my email address, choose a login name and then a password in order to watch a news clip or an episode of Lost. Why did I have to do this? Was I added to some list or did they sell my information? These are the reasons why you don’t ask for login for simple things such as video. And furthermore, I could never remember that I had created a login, so when I wanted to watch something again, I had to create another profile. With the increase of video online, this has changed and changed for the better.
7. Please get out of my way
In this section of Seth Godin’s book, he praises Yahoo for having a fast loading page with a direct “banana” to check your email. Email, of course, was one of the main purposes of Yahoo ten years ago, when the book was written. If The Big Red Fez was written today, I think Godin would think differently of Yahoo’s main page and their email “banana.” To start, Yahoo is more about searching and news than it is about email. Their front page is cluttered with many “bananas” other than email.

However, I still use Yahoo for my personal email, but here is my gripe about it. You go to the main page, sign in, and then press mail. Seems straight forward, just like Godin says in his book, but it isn’t. It should go directly to your inbox, but does it? Nope. It goes to this page:

So then you have to press the button for your inbox or the check mail button. That’s two steps to check your mailbox, when it should only be one. This absolutely drives me crazy and Godin would agree with me.
8. Spam is the eye of the beholder
As much as I hate drop down menus, I hate spam even more. I don’t click on advertisements because I remember the time that if you click on anything other than a link, you got a thousand pop-ups. I also don’t usually sign up for any sweepstakes, offers or promotions, because I fear that if I do my inbox will be bombarded with spam. Well, against my better judgment I signed up for the free coupons offered at US post office online, when I was changing my address online. Why should I fear it, they were all legitimate companies and maybe there would be some good offers. Well, I should have followed my gut. My inbox immediately got numerous emails from these companies. Why does overstock.com send me 10 emails a day? Is there anyone out there that wants 10 emails from anyone? I checked one box saying I would like a coupon and all of a sudden I’m getting notifications for lingerie and makeup sales. I spent the better part of a week, continuously checking my email and unsubscribing to corporate emails. It’s a horrible way to do business.
9. Membership has its privileges
I am a member of the American Leman Series (a sports car racing site) website or at least I thought I was. I joined in 2005 to read the forums and again in 2006 when they updated their forums and yet again when they updated their forums in 2008. I said at least I thought I was, because now when I go to the webpage, and sign in, there is no record of me. Even better, they no longer have forums. How hard is it to update your site and retain the information people have already gotten you? Well now when I go to the site, I don’t have the option to visit the forums, but I do like to look at the pictures, however, you have to sign up to view the pictures. Why? If someone new wants to see a product in action, why do they have to register? I wonder how many people do that? None, that’s how many. If you have a product and loyal visitors, you want to make it easier for them to visit, not harder.
10. Every once in a while it’s okay to use a pop-up
Again, I disagree with Godin. Ten years ago, you couldn’t control pop-up, but now you can. Internet Explorer has a pop-up blocker that stops these pesky annoyances. So when a site wants to use a pop-up, IE sends you a warning notice your screen, you have to click on it and allow it to temporary allow pop-ups. Then the page has to reload as well as the pop-up. Technology has gotten the better of Godin’s theory and websites should avoid pop-ups and just load another page.